Chaos and Order

💡 왼쪽 원문을 읽으면서 오른쪽에 따라 써보세요. Tab 키로 힌트를 받을 수 있습니다.

원문 렌더가 준비되기 전까지 텍스트 가이드로 표시합니다.

Introduction

In March 2024, Intuit shut down Mint. The de facto standard for U.S. personal finance for nearly 25 years vanished, and millions of users had six weeks to find a new home. The shockwave made Monarch Money, Copilot Money, and Lunch Money grow explosively, and added new inflows on top of YNAB's already loyal base.

This post is a single-post map as of May 2026 — two years after the Mint shutdown, when the first wave of resettlement has finished. It covers which budgeting / net-worth / expense-tracking tools survived and who should pick what. The U.S., Korea, and Japan are all included.

1. The 2026 Personal Finance Tool Map — Post-Mint Landscape

First, the big picture. As of May 2026, the major tools, sorted by category, look like this.

|---------|--------------------|------|------|

| Data infrastructure | Plaid / Yodlee / MX | (B2B) | U.S. |

This post walks through nearly every row.

1.1 Big-Picture Changes Between 2024 and 2026

- **Mint shutdown (March 23, 2024)** — Intuit shuttered Mint and pushed users toward Credit Karma.

- **Monarch Money explosion** — In a public interview, Monarch said it grew its user base roughly 20x in March–April 2024. Price stayed at $99/year.

- **Copilot funding + Android beta** — Android beta announced in 2024, full release in 2025 (iOS is still the showcase).

- **YNAB price stabilization** — Settled at $14.99/month, $109/year.

- **Actual Budget fork + flourishing** — Community-driven development after the Shift Reset handover, self-hosted server + mobile PWA is the standard pattern.

- **Plaid dominance vs Finicity vs MX** — Plaid is still the U.S. default, but Visa's Tink, Mastercard's Finicity, and MX have made inroads in some tools.

- **Korea MyData year two+** — Toss, Banksalad, KakaoBank split the market. Banksalad was acquired by Shinhan Card in 2024, reshaping the field.

- **Japan** — Money Forward ME is effectively the standard; Zaim is the free / simple camp; freee owns the self-employed / SMB segment.

1.2 Classification — Tracker vs Budget vs Net Worth

The three categories satisfy different desires.

- **Expense tracker** — "Where did my money go last month?" Backward-looking. Mint, Money Forward ME, Toss Asset live here.

- **Budgeting** — "How much can I spend this month?" Allocates forward. YNAB and Actual Budget are the archetypes.

- **Net-worth tracker** — "How is my net worth moving?" Unified view across accounts. Empower and Monarch are strong.

One tool can cover more than one, but each has a sweet spot. Monarch is tracker + net worth; Copilot is tracker + UX; YNAB is pure envelope budgeting; Empower is net-worth and retirement planning.

2. The Mint Shutdown (March 2024) — What Actually Changed

On March 23, 2024, Intuit officially shut down Mint. It was not just a service ending but a tectonic shift in the U.S. personal-finance tool market.

2.1 Why It Shut Down

Combining the public reasons and industry analysis:

- **Revenue model limits** — Mint was free + ad referrals, which contributed little to Intuit revenue.

- **Credit Karma integration intent** — Intuit acquired Credit Karma in 2020 and wanted credit + budgeting on one platform.

- **Maintenance burden** — Mint had to keep 16,000+ financial institution links alive, and the codebase had aged.

- **TurboTax / QuickBooks priority** — Intuit's flagship SaaS lived elsewhere, and Mint sat in their shadow.

2.2 Migration in Practice

Mint users were pointed at Credit Karma, but in practice many could not continue their budgeting workflow there.

- Credit Karma centers on credit score + card/loan recommendations rather than budgeting.

- Transaction categorization, budget setup, and multi-account unified visualization are weaker than Mint.

- Result — users scattered to Monarch, Copilot, YNAB, Empower, and Lunch Money.

2.3 Lessons from the Mint Shutdown

- **Limits of free-tool sustainability** — Ad / data revenue models eventually can't pay the data-aggregation bill.

- **Paid budgeting normalized** — The market's price expectation, broken by Mint, recovered. Tools charging $5–15/month gathered users.

- **Self-hosted / open-source revival** — Actual Budget benefited unexpectedly. "I own my data" gained momentum.

- **Visible aggregation dependence** — Everyone realized every tool depends on Plaid / Yodlee infrastructure.

3. Monarch Money — Champion of the Mint Successors

The biggest beneficiary of the Mint shutdown is, without question, Monarch Money.

3.1 What It Is

- **Founded** — 2018, by former Mint team members.

- **Positioning** — A paid rebuild of Mint's "all-in-one + net worth" DNA.

- **Price** — $14.99/month or $99.99/year. 7-day free trial.

- **Platforms** — Web + iOS + Android.

3.2 Feature Summary

- **Account aggregation** — Plaid + Finicity + direct connections to 16,000+ U.S. financial institutions.

- **Asset aggregation** — Real estate (Zillow value link), vehicles, crypto, manual accounts.

- **Auto-categorization** — Machine-learning-based, with user-defined rules.

- **Shared household budgeting** — Multiple users in one account for spouses / partners — something Mint never had.

- **Goal setting** — Emergency funds, debt payoff, retirement tracked per goal.

- **Cash flow + net worth charts** — Time series at a glance.

3.3 Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

- Inherits Mint's UX well, so the learning curve is low.

- Shared budgets are attractive to couples.

- Mobile and web are both polished and sync smoothly.

Weaknesses:

- $99/year is on the expensive side for a budgeting tool.

- Aggregation occasionally drops — even at big banks, temporary sync failures are reported.

- Almost no Korean or Japanese bank coverage (U.S. / Canada focused).

4. Copilot Money — iOS-Only Beautiful Design

If you live on iOS, Copilot Money gets near-religious recommendations.

4.1 What It Is

- **Founded** — 2019, by ex-Google / Square engineers.

- **Positioning** — "Design-first" tracker. Apple Design Award 2021 winner.

- **Price** — $13/month or $95/year. First month free (codes can extend to two).

- **Platforms** — iOS / macOS native first. Android entered beta in 2024 and shipped in 2025.

4.2 Feature Summary

- **AI-powered categorization** — Copilot's signature. Gets sharper as it learns.

- **Crypto tracking** — Coinbase, Binance, Kraken connections.

- **Investments + budget + real estate** — Net worth in one screen.

- **Widgets, Siri, Home Screen integration** — Depth inside the Apple ecosystem.

- **Manual transaction UX** — Card-purchase notification → one tap to categorize, fast and fluid.

4.3 Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

- Design — not surface aesthetics but a strong balance of "information density vs clarity."

- iOS-native speed — hard for Monarch or YNAB to match.

- Per-user ML categorization improves over time.

Weaknesses:

- Weak for users outside the U.S. (Plaid-dependent).

- The Android release happened, but it's not as smooth as iOS.

- Shared household features are weaker than Monarch.

5. YNAB (You Need A Budget) — Methodology + Tool

YNAB is not just an app — it's a budgeting philosophy. After a year you naturally become "a YNAB person" or you can't stand it and move to something else.

5.1 The Four Rules

YNAB's method is summarized in four rules.

1. **Give every dollar a job** — Money coming in is immediately assigned to a category. Zero unassigned dollars is the steady state.

2. **Embrace your true expenses** — Annual insurance or car registration is set aside one-twelfth each month.

3. **Roll with the punches** — When one category overflows, you can move money from another. No guilt.

4. **Age your money** — Grow the metric for how many days, on average, your dollars sit before being spent (Age of Money).

This philosophy is the most polished implementation of "budget first, then spend."

5.2 Price and Tool

- **Price** — $14.99/month or $109/year. 34-day free trial.

- **Free tier** — Students get one year free (YNAB for Students).

- **Platforms** — Web + iOS + Android. There's a learning curve, but it's fast once internalized.

5.3 Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

- The methodology is powerful. It changes the user's "budgeting mindset."

- Encourages the user to decide rather than auto-categorizing — intentionality is the core.

- Works well for couples (multi-user supported).

Weaknesses:

- Steep learning curve. Without internalizing the four rules, it ends up as an expensive tracker.

- Net worth / asset tracking is weak — focused on budgeting.

- Auto / ML categorization is weaker than Monarch or Copilot (a deliberate choice).

- Ongoing dissatisfaction with the price increases.

6. Actual Budget — Open Source, Free, Self-Hosted

Actual Budget has the philosophy closest to YNAB, but it's fully open source and free.

6.1 What It Is

- **Origin** — A paid desktop app from Shift Reset LLC; went open source in 2022.

- **Today** — Community-driven, GitHub repository actualbudget/actual.

- **Price** — Free. Only your server cost if you self-host.

- **Platforms** — Web + iOS PWA + Android PWA + desktop.

6.2 Core Properties

- **Envelope budgeting** — Almost identical philosophy to YNAB.

- **Local-first sync** — Data is stored on your device; the server is just a sync backend.

- **Self-hosting** — Runs as a one-line Docker, deploys on NAS / Raspberry Pi / home server.

- **GoCardless / SimpleFIN aggregation** — Some European and U.S. bank direct connections (limited).

- **Transaction import** — Universal CSV / OFX / QFX manual import covers any bank.

6.3 Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

- Free, open source, full data sovereignty.

- Ideal for users who love YNAB's philosophy but can't justify the subscription.

- You can directly modify the code or write plugins.

Weaknesses:

- Self-hosting required — without Docker / NAS knowledge, the entry barrier is real.

- Automatic bank aggregation is limited to some large U.S. banks.

- Mobile is PWA — not a true native UX.

- Shared household budgeting takes extra setup.

7. Lunch Money — Indie Bootstrapped ($120/year)

Lunch Money started as a solo project by Jen Yip and is still run by a small focused team in 2026.

7.1 What It Is

- **Founded** — 2020, bootstrapped by Jen Yip.

- **Positioning** — Global, multi-currency tracker. Plaid + currencies + crypto in one place.

- **Price** — $120/year. 14-day free trial.

- **Platforms** — Web-first; PWA + iOS / Android native.

7.2 Feature Summary

- **Multi-currency tracking** — Strong for travelers and expats. Auto-conversion for USD, EUR, JPY, KRW, and many more.

- **Crypto** — Coinbase, Binance, and friends.

- **Global bank aggregation** — Plaid (U.S.) + GoCardless (Europe) + manual import.

- **Developer-friendly API** — REST API for self-automation, Notion / Airtable integrations.

- **Categories + tags + groups** — Flexible classification.

7.3 Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

- Fits global users — partial coverage for Korea / Japan / Europe.

- Open API lets developers build their own automations.

- Solo-team feedback loop is fast (Discord-run).

Weaknesses:

- $120/year is pricey.

- Net worth tracking is weaker than Monarch.

- Korean / Japanese banks mostly need manual import (weak automatic aggregation).

8. Empower (formerly Personal Capital) — Wealth Tracking

Empower is a "net worth and retirement planning" tool more than a budget tool.

8.1 What It Is

- **Original name** — Personal Capital, founded 2009.

- **Change** — Acquired by Empower Retirement in 2020; brand unified as Empower Personal Dashboard in 2023.

- **Positioning** — Net worth + investment analysis + retirement planning.

- **Price** — Dashboard is free. Advisory service charges a fee on assets under management.

- **Platforms** — Web + iOS + Android.

8.2 Feature Summary

- **Net worth chart** — All accounts (checking, savings, brokerage, 401k, IRA, real estate) unified.

- **Investment Checkup** — Asset allocation, fees, and holdings analysis.

- **Retirement Planner** — Monte Carlo simulation for retirement viability.

- **Fee Analyzer** — Visualizes how fund fees erode retirement assets.

8.3 Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

- Free net worth and investment analysis. Effectively a U.S. standard.

- Retirement planning depth no budget app can touch.

- Strong 401k connections.

Weaknesses:

- Free users receive advisory sales calls (notorious).

- Budgeting / tracking features are weak — asset-centric.

- Almost meaningless for users outside the U.S.

9. Credit Karma — Intuit's Mint Replacement

Officially the migration path for Mint users, but in practice many had to go elsewhere.

9.1 What It Is

- **Original purpose** — Free credit score + credit report monitoring.

- **Intuit acquisition (2020)** — Sits in Intuit's personal finance lineup with TurboTax and Mint.

- **Mint-replacement additions** — Transaction categories, budgets, some net-worth views.

9.2 Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

- Free, ad-supported.

- Excellent credit score monitoring.

- Credit card / loan recommendations are useful in some cases.

Weaknesses:

- Tracker features fall far short of Mint.

- Ads / referrals are the core revenue, and UX is optimized around them.

- Budget, category, and asset integration are weak — Mint users found this most disappointing.

9.3 Verdict

For Mint users Credit Karma is rated as "officially the successor but not actually." Anyone missing the Mint UX typically goes to Monarch or Copilot.

10. Quicken Simplifi / Tiller / PocketSmith

These three carve out a different niche from Mint and Monarch.

10.1 Quicken Simplifi

- **Release** — 2020, the cloud / mobile version of desktop Quicken.

- **Price** — $47.88/year (about $4/month). The price-to-value leader.

- **Platforms** — Web + iOS + Android.

- **Strengths** — Quicken brand stability, broad U.S. data aggregation, low price.

- **Weaknesses** — UX is a bit conservative, shared household features are limited.

10.2 Tiller

- **Positioning** — Google Sheets / Excel-based budgeting.

- **Price** — $79/year.

- **How it works** — Tiller pushes daily transactions into your sheet. Analysis happens in the sheet.

- **Strengths** — Direct spreadsheet analysis / reporting. Total processing freedom.

- **Weaknesses** — You have to know your way around a spreadsheet. Non-technical users face a steep climb.

10.3 PocketSmith

- **Release** — 2008, out of New Zealand.

- **Price** — $7.50–$24.95/month (by plan).

- **Strengths** — Multi-country, multi-currency, future cash-flow forecasting. Appealing for expats.

- **Weaknesses** — UX feels somewhat dated, learning curve exists.

11. Plaid + Yodlee — Open Banking Data

About 90% of budgeting tools rely on Plaid, Yodlee, MX, or Finicity infrastructure.

11.1 Plaid

- **Founded** — 2013, San Francisco.

- **Positioning** — De facto standard API in the U.S. Used by Venmo, Cash App, Robinhood, Monarch, Copilot, and more.

- **Bank coverage** — 12,000+ across U.S., Canada, UK, and parts of Europe.

- **Business model** — Charges tool companies for API usage (B2B).

11.2 Yodlee

- **Founded** — 1999, far older than Plaid.

- **Positioning** — Strong global coverage. Used by Mint, Empower, and some global fintechs.

- **Acquisition** — Acquired by Envestnet in 2015.

- **Strengths** — Some coverage outside the U.S. (Asia, Latin America).

11.3 Finicity / MX

- **Finicity** — A Mastercard subsidiary, Plaid's main U.S. competitor.

- **MX** — Utah-based, strong with credit unions and community banks.

11.4 Open Banking Trends

- **CFPB 1033 rule (U.S.)** — Finalized in 2024, obliging banks to make consumer data available to third-party apps. Favorable to Plaid and the aggregation industry.

- **PSD2 (Europe)** — In force since 2018. European tools use PSD2-based APIs like GoCardless and TrueLayer.

- **Korea MyData** — Fully launched in 2022. Toss, Banksalad, and KakaoBank hold licenses.

- **Japan** — No formal Open Banking mandate, but Money Forward and Zaim connect via bilateral bank agreements.

12. Korea — Toss Asset / Banksalad / KakaoBank MyData

Korea's tracker market is effectively consolidated since MyData launched in 2022.

12.1 Toss Asset

- **Operator** — Toss (Viva Republica).

- **Positioning** — Tracker + net worth inside the Toss money-transfer / brokerage app.

- **Price** — Free.

- **Strengths** — Largest Korean user base; the broadest bank / card / brokerage MyData aggregation.

- **Weaknesses** — Category / budget depth is weaker than dedicated trackers. Asset tracking is the focus.

12.2 Banksalad

- **Operator** — Rainist → acquired by Shinhan Card in 2024.

- **Positioning** — Korea's first MyData-based tracker.

- **Price** — Free.

- **Strengths** — Deep auto-categorization and spending analysis. Has experimented with health / DNA-test lifestyle features.

- **Weaknesses** — Post-acquisition integration and UX changes ongoing. Some users have moved to Toss or KakaoBank.

12.3 KakaoBank MyData

- **Operator** — KakaoBank.

- **Positioning** — Tracker baked into the bank app.

- **Price** — Free.

- **Strengths** — Convenience for KakaoBank account holders. KakaoTalk notification ties.

- **Weaknesses** — Aggregation of other banks / cards is shallower than Toss.

12.4 Monilab / Others

- **Monilab** — Tracker for sole proprietors and freelancers.

- **Pyeonhan Gagyeobu / Clover** — Manual trackers from the pre-Toss / Banksalad generation (still used by some).

12.5 Korea Recommendation

- General user — Toss Asset.

- Going deep on categories and spending analysis — Banksalad.

- KakaoBank as primary bank — KakaoBank MyData.

- Wants data sovereignty + Korean bank links — currently hard. Manual import + Actual Budget combo.

13. Japan — Money Forward ME / Zaim / freee

Japan has the Korea-style MyData feel but a thicker dedicated-tracker SaaS market.

13.1 Money Forward ME

- **Operator** — Money Forward, Inc. (TSE first section listed).

- **Positioning** — The de facto standard personal tracker in Japan.

- **Price** — Free + premium (500 yen/month, 5,300 yen/year).

- **Aggregation** — 2,500+ Japanese financial institutions (banks, cards, brokerage, e-money, point programs).

- **Strengths** — Number-one Japan coverage. Assets, investments, and pensions integrated.

- **Weaknesses** — Free plan limits linked accounts (currently 4) and data retention (1 year on free).

13.2 Zaim

- **Operator** — Zaim K.K. Acquired by Credit Saison in 2024.

- **Positioning** — Simple / free tracker.

- **Price** — Free + premium (480 yen/month).

- **Strengths** — Simple UX, receipt OCR, family sharing.

- **Weaknesses** — Aggregation depth weaker than Money Forward.

13.3 freee Tracker

- **Operator** — freee, the leader in self-employed / SMB accounting SaaS.

- **Positioning** — Lets sole proprietors / freelancers manage business and personal together.

- **Price** — Free + premium.

- **Strengths** — Business accounting integration, tax filing connection.

- **Weaknesses** — As a pure personal tracker, Money Forward is smoother.

13.4 Others

- **OkaneRekko** — Input-centric mobile tracker.

- **B/43** — Shared family budget + prepaid card combo.

13.5 Japan Recommendation

- General user — Money Forward ME.

- Free / simple — Zaim.

- Self-employed / freelancer — freee.

14. Who Should Pick What — U.S. / Korea / Japan / Self-Hosted

Finally, a decision tree by country and priority.

14.1 U.S. Residents

- **Was a Mint user, wants the closest successor** → Monarch Money.

- **iOS user with strong design taste** → Copilot Money.

- **Wants to learn budgeting seriously** → YNAB.

- **Net worth / retirement planning focused** → Empower (separate tracker).

- **Best price-to-value** → Quicken Simplifi.

- **Spreadsheet enthusiast** → Tiller.

- **Insists on free** → Credit Karma + Empower combo. Or Actual Budget self-hosted.

14.2 Korea Residents

- **General user** → Toss Asset.

- **Deep category analysis and spending patterns** → Banksalad.

- **KakaoBank as primary** → KakaoBank MyData.

- **Wants data sovereignty + accepts losing some auto-aggregation** → Actual Budget manual import.

14.3 Japan Residents

- **General user** → Money Forward ME (premium recommended).

- **Free / simple** → Zaim.

- **Self-employed** → freee.

14.4 Global / Expats

- **Multi-country / multi-currency** → PocketSmith or Lunch Money.

- **Developer-friendly + API automation** → Lunch Money.

- **Full data sovereignty + self-hosting** → Actual Budget.

14.5 Couples / Family Shared Budgeting

- **U.S.** → Monarch (multi-user supported).

- **Korea** → Toss Asset (family sharing).

- **Japan** → B/43 or Zaim.

14.6 Absolutely Insists on Free

- **U.S.** → Empower (net worth) + Credit Karma (tracker) + manual.

- **Global** → Actual Budget self-hosted.

- **Korea / Japan** → Free MyData / tracker apps (Toss, Money Forward free tier).

15. References

- Monarch Money — https://www.monarchmoney.com/

- Copilot Money — https://copilot.money/

- YNAB — https://www.ynab.com/

- Actual Budget — https://actualbudget.org/

- Actual Budget GitHub — https://github.com/actualbudget/actual

- Lunch Money — https://lunchmoney.app/

- Empower Personal Dashboard — https://www.empower.com/personal-dashboard

- Credit Karma — https://www.creditkarma.com/

- Quicken Simplifi — https://www.quicken.com/products/simplifi/

- Tiller — https://www.tillerhq.com/

- PocketSmith — https://www.pocketsmith.com/

- Plaid — https://plaid.com/

- Yodlee — https://www.yodlee.com/

- Finicity (Mastercard) — https://www.finicity.com/

- MX — https://www.mx.com/

- CFPB 1033 rule — https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/final-rules/required-rulemaking-on-personal-financial-data-rights/

- Mint shutdown FAQ (Intuit) — https://help.mint.com/Articles/Mint-FAQ

- Toss — https://toss.im/

- Banksalad — https://www.banksalad.com/

- KakaoBank — https://www.kakaobank.com/

- Money Forward ME — https://moneyforward.com/

- Zaim — https://zaim.net/

- freee — https://www.freee.co.jp/

- B/43 — https://b43.jp/

- Korea MyData portal — https://www.mydatacenter.or.kr/