Skip to content
←

필사 모드: Wuthering Heights — A Chronicle of Destructive Love

English
0%
정확도 0%
💡 왼쪽 원문을 읽으면서 오른쪽에 따라 써보세요. Tab 키로 힌트를 받을 수 있습니다.

Opening — The Wind on the Moors

The story begins with a house battered by wind.

It stands on a hill above the bleak Yorkshire moors, where the trees all lean the same way.

The house is called Wuthering Heights.

A stranger comes to knock at its door.

Instead of a welcome, he meets snarling dogs, a curt master, and a tension he cannot explain.

Trapped by a snowstorm that night, he dreams that the cold hand of a long-dead girl grips him at the window.

This uneasy first visit is the key that opens the whole novel.

Emily Brontë's Wuthering Heights, published in 1847, was her only novel.

This essay looks in turn at the author and her setting, the unusual narration, the love and revenge that span two generations, and how the book was judged then and now.

Finally, we consider how a reader today might approach this romance that refuses to be sentimental.

1. Emily Brontë and the Yorkshire Moors

Emily Brontë was born in 1818 in Yorkshire, in the north of England.

Her family lived in the parsonage of a small village called Haworth.

Just behind the parsonage lay the endless open country of the moors, the moorland.

Emily loved this rough, windswept land deeply.

For her, the moor was not a backdrop but almost a living presence.

Three Sisters in a Parsonage

The Brontë family had three gifted sisters.

The eldest was Charlotte, then Emily, then Anne.

Charlotte wrote Jane Eyre, and Anne left Agnes Grey and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall.

From childhood the sisters invented imaginary kingdoms and wrote stories together.

Isolation and early loss turned their imaginations sharply inward.

The Mask of Ellis Bell

In 1846, the three sisters paid to publish a book of poems.

They used masculine-sounding pen names instead of their own.

Charlotte was Currer Bell, Emily was Ellis Bell, and Anne was Acton Bell.

It was a choice meant to avoid the prejudice against women writers of the time.

Wuthering Heights, too, first reached the world under the name Ellis Bell.

Emily died of tuberculosis in 1848, barely a year after the novel appeared.

She never learned how highly her book would one day be regarded.

2. A Frame Within a Frame — Unreliable Narrators

Wuthering Heights does not simply list its events.

The way the story is delivered is itself carefully built.

Lockwood, the Outsider

The first narrator is a man named Lockwood.

He is a tenant from the city who rents a house near Wuthering Heights.

Lockwood is an outsider who knows nothing of the local history.

His bewilderment is soon the reader's bewilderment too.

He records what he sees and hears as if keeping a diary.

Nelly Dean, the Insider

The second and more important narrator is Nelly Dean.

Nelly is a housekeeper who has long served both households.

She has witnessed most of the events at first hand.

When Lockwood grows curious, Nelly tells him the story of the past years.

So a large part of the novel takes the form of Nelly's recollection to Lockwood.

Can We Trust These Voices

This structure is called nested or framed narration.

It is a way of placing one story inside another.

Yet neither narrator is fully objective.

Lockwood is a naïve observer who often misreads a situation.

Nelly was directly involved, and she colours the story with her own judgements and feelings.

The reader must listen through a filter rather than take their words at face value.

This distance actually adds depth and tension to the story.

We piece together fragments as they are passed along, not the whole of the truth.

3. Heathcliff and Catherine — Passion, Not Comfort

At the centre of the novel stand two figures.

They are Heathcliff and Catherine Earnshaw.

A Child Brought Home

Heathcliff is an orphan whom old Mr. Earnshaw brings back from the streets of Liverpool as a boy.

His origins and parentage are never explained.

Some of the family treat him coldly as a stranger.

But Catherine alone grows deeply close to him.

The two children run wild together across the moors.

I Am Heathcliff

Catherine later speaks a famous line.

She says her soul and Heathcliff's are made of the same substance.

This is not a tender, comfortable confession of love.

It is rather a fierce identification, each finding the self in the other.

Their bond is closer to possession than to consolation.

A Love That Refuses Ease

Catherine finally marries the wealthy and well-mannered Edgar Linton.

She loves Heathcliff yet chooses social security.

This choice becomes the trigger for the whole tragedy.

Heathcliff takes it as a betrayal, vanishes, and then returns.

Their relationship is far from peaceful.

It is a force that draws them together and destroys them at once.

Many readers feel this bond as romantic, yet a cruelty runs through it.

4. The Moor as an Elemental Force

In this novel the setting is not a mere stage prop.

The moor works almost as a character in its own right.

Two Houses, Two Worlds

The story features two contrasting houses.

One is Wuthering Heights.

It stands harshly on high, windswept ground.

The other is Thrushcross Grange, down in the valley.

This is a comparatively elegant and comfortable home.

Weather and Feeling

The word wuthering is a local dialect term for stormy, turbulent weather.

The very name of the house already carries wild weather within it.

Wind, snow, and mist often overlap with the passions of the characters.

When the weather rages, the people's hearts rage too.

Nature is both a mirror of the characters and a power in itself.

Something Untamed

The moor is not the tidy nature of a garden.

It is a wild space that human beings cannot fully control.

The love of Heathcliff and Catherine resembles this wildness.

It is a raw emotion not smoothed by the rules of society.

This close binding of setting and character is a defining feature of the novel.

5. Obsession and Destruction Across Two Generations

The love in Wuthering Heights does not end with one generation.

Its aftermath stretches far into the next.

The First Generation's Tragedy

The first generation includes Catherine, Heathcliff, and Edgar.

Catherine's choice and Heathcliff's fury entangle and bring on catastrophe.

Catherine dies young, soon after giving birth to a daughter.

Heathcliff turns the grief of losing her into hatred.

His love now becomes the engine of revenge.

A Shadow Over the Children

The second generation includes Catherine's daughter, Cathy.

It also includes Heathcliff's son, Linton, and Hindley's son, Hareton.

Heathcliff uses these young people in his plan of revenge.

The wounds of the parents' generation weigh on the children's lives.

The harm born of love repeats itself across generations.

Love as Possession

In this novel love often takes the shape of possession.

The desire to own another person entirely distorts the relationship.

Heathcliff even reaches for the property and children of those he once loved.

Obsession at first wears the face of love.

But it turns, in the end, into a force that eats away at everyone.

The two-generation story slowly reveals this process of corruption.

6. Revenge and Its Corrosive Cost

Heathcliff's revenge is a major axis of the novel.

And Brontë does not glamorise it.

A Carefully Prepared Revenge

The returned Heathcliff moves with patience and persistence.

He exploits Hindley's gambling to gain Wuthering Heights.

He marries Edgar's sister and shakes the Linton family as well.

His plan is not impulsive anger but a long-sharpened strategy.

The Barrenness of the Avenger

Yet revenge does not set Heathcliff free.

Even as he seizes each thing he wanted, he grows more barren inside.

Hatred consumes not only its targets but the one who feels it.

Those around him are swept into his revenge and wounded with him.

Revenge repays a wound but does not heal it.

The Emptiness at the End

At the close of the novel, Heathcliff even loses his appetite for revenge.

The moment he holds all the power, it becomes meaningless.

For what he truly wanted was never property or dominion.

He fades away in his longing for the Catherine who is already gone.

Brontë quietly shows that at the end of revenge lies emptiness, not victory.

At this point the novel moves beyond a simple tale of vengeance.

7. The Shocked and Hostile Reception of 1847

Wuthering Heights was not warmly welcomed when it appeared.

Many critics instead expressed dismay at the novel.

Charged With Being Coarse and Dark

Victorian readers were used to morally instructive fiction.

By that standard the book looked far too coarse and dark.

Heathcliff's cruelty and the characters' passions were felt as disturbing.

Some reviewers called the novel savage or morbid.

Confusion Over the Author

Because of the pen name Ellis Bell, speculation about the author ran high.

Some guessed that the writer of such a story must be a rough, harsh man.

The fact that the author was a young woman remained unknown for a long time.

A Sister's Defence

After Emily's death, Charlotte stepped forward.

Charlotte added a preface to the 1850 edition to introduce her sister's novel.

She defended the book as rough but honest.

At the same time, even she expressed surprise at the darkness in her sister's imagination.

Thus the early reception was closer to shock than to admiration.

Only with the passing of time was the depth of this novel rediscovered.

8. A Love Story or a Study of Love's Cruelty

Here lies the greatest debate surrounding Wuthering Heights today.

Is the book a great love story, or a study that lays bare the destructiveness of love?

Reading It as Romance

Some readers take the novel as a narrative of intense love.

A bond that not even death can sever certainly looks romantic.

The longing for Catherine and Heathcliff to be united wins sympathy across the ages.

In popular culture the book has often been consumed as passionate romance.

Reading It as Warning

Other readers, however, read it in the opposite way.

They see the book as showing how much uncontrolled passion destroys.

The lovers' passion inflicts endless suffering on those around them.

That love is less beautiful than it is cruel and selfish.

From this view the novel is not a hymn to romance but a warning about its danger.

Why Both Readings Coexist

Interestingly, both interpretations can find support in the text.

Brontë does not force an answer to either side.

She simply shows the ecstasy and the destruction of love at once.

So the novel reveals a different face depending on who reads it.

It is exactly this ambiguity that keeps the work alive for so long.

Two Houses and Two Generations

The diagram below sets out, in a simple way, the relationship of the two houses and the two generations.

      [ WUTHERING HEIGHTS ]           [ THRUSHCROSS GRANGE ]
      high on windy ground            snug down in the valley
      the Earnshaw family             the Linton family
            |                                |
   -------------------              -------------------
   Generation 1                        Generation 1
   Catherine Earnshaw === Heathcliff(outsider)   Edgar Linton
        |                                     |
        +-------------------------------------+
                        |
   -------------------                      -------------------
   Generation 2                                Generation 2
   Cathy Linton --- Linton Heathcliff / Hareton Earnshaw
   (in the next generation the wounds slowly begin to heal)

This layout shows how the passion of the first generation carries into the second.

In the second generation the story turns, little by little, from destruction toward recovery.

9. How to Read an Unsentimental Romance Today

So how might we approach this book now?

Here are a few balanced attitudes to suggest.

Read Without Idealising

First, it is best not to idealise the lovers without reservation.

The bond of Heathcliff and Catherine is intense but not healthy.

Be moved by that intensity, yet keep an eye on its cost as well.

Stay Aware of the Layers of Narration

Second, it helps to remember that the story reaches us through several narrators.

What we read is not the events themselves but someone's account of them.

Keeping this distance in mind lets us understand the characters more fully.

Feel the Setting Along the Way

Third, it is better not to let the moor slip past like background noise.

Wind and weather are tightly bound up with the characters' feelings.

Imagining the landscape makes the mood of the novel land far more deeply.

Suspend Judgement

Fourth, it matters not to force a single answer onto the book.

You may read it as a love story, or as a study of love's cruelty.

Carrying your own questions between the two readings is the way to enjoy this novel.

Readers who are used to handling complex systems, engineers in particular, may find that savouring the layered structure itself suits them better than reaching for a tidy conclusion.

Closing — The Wind Still Blows

Wuthering Heights is not a comfortable novel.

The book holds out both the bright and the dark sides of love together.

The story of Heathcliff and Catherine is at once entrancing and destructive.

Emily Brontë shows both sides honestly, hiding neither.

That is why the novel is not read once and forgotten.

The shock of its first appearance has turned, over time, into admiration for its depth.

The wind on the moors is still blowing after the novel ends.

Listening to that wind is left entirely to the reader.

Questions to Ponder

  1. How should we judge Catherine's choice of Edgar over Heathcliff — is it a betrayal, or a realistic decision?

  2. Up to what point can Heathcliff's revenge be understood, and where does it become hard to justify?

  3. When the story reaches us through the unreliable narrators Lockwood and Nelly Dean, what do we gain and what do we lose?

  4. Do you see this novel as a great love story or as a warning about love's destructiveness, and on what grounds do you choose?

References

현재 단락 (1/198)

The story begins with a house battered by wind.

작성 글자: 0자원문 글자: 11,813자작성 단락: 0/198