Split View: eVTOL 기업 분석 - Joby, Archer, Vertical Aerospace 심층 비교

eVTOL Company Analysis - Deep Dive Comparison of Joby, Archer, and Vertical Aerospace

• Introduction: What is eVTOL and Why Does It Matter
  • UAM Market Size Projections
• Joby Aviation (JOBY) Deep Dive
  • Company Overview
  • S4 Aircraft Specifications
  • Key Partnerships and Investments
  • FAA Certification Progress
  • Business Model
• Archer Aviation (ACHR) Deep Dive
  • Company Overview
  • Midnight Aircraft Specifications
  • Key Partnerships and Investments
  • LA 2028 Olympics Target
  • Manufacturing Strategy
• Vertical Aerospace (EVTL) Deep Dive
  • Company Overview
  • VX4 Aircraft Specifications
  • Key Partnerships and Investments
  • European Market Focus Strategy
  • Order Book Status
• Aircraft Specifications Comparison Table
• FAA/EASA Certification Process and Timeline
  • Understanding Certification Requirements
  • Part 135 vs Part 91
  • Certification Timeline
  • FAA Special Conditions
• Infrastructure Challenges: Vertiports, Charging, and Air Traffic Management
  • Vertiports
  • Charging Infrastructure
  • Air Traffic Management (ATM/UTM)
• Financial Comparison Analysis
  • Cash Position and Burn Rate
  • Revenue Generation Timeline
  • TAM (Total Addressable Market) Claims
• Competitive Landscape: Other Key Players
  • Lilium - Lessons from Bankruptcy
  • EHang (China)
  • Wisk Aero (Boeing-Backed)
  • Other Notable Companies
• Key Risk Factors
  • 1. Certification Delay Risk
  • 2. Battery Technology Limitations
  • 3. Public Acceptance
  • 4. Regulatory Environment
  • 5. Intensifying Competition and Funding Shortages
• FAQ
• What is the biggest difference between eVTOL and helicopters?
• Which company is the most promising among Joby, Archer, and Vertical?
• What is the expected price of an eVTOL air taxi ride?
• Are eVTOLs safe?
• Is UAM service possible in Korea?
• References
• Practical Takeaway
  • Investor Checklist
  • Investment Scenarios
  • Key Message
• Quiz

Introduction: What is eVTOL and Why Does It Matter

eVTOL (electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing) refers to aircraft capable of vertical takeoff and landing using electric power. While they may resemble helicopters, the use of electric motors creates fundamental differences: significantly lower noise levels, reduced operating costs, and zero carbon emissions.

eVTOL aircraft are receiving enormous attention as the core vehicle for Urban Air Mobility (UAM), with the potential to dramatically reduce short-distance travel times within cities. For example, the journey from Manhattan to JFK Airport, which takes over an hour by car, could be completed in approximately 7 minutes by eVTOL.

UAM Market Size Projections

Leading financial institutions and consulting firms project the UAM market as follows:

• Morgan Stanley: Forecasts the global UAM market to reach approximately $1.5 trillion by 2040
• McKinsey: Predicts the Advanced Air Mobility (AAM) market will reach $30 billion annually by 2030
• Deloitte: Projects the US AAM market alone will grow to $115 billion by 2035
• Roland Berger: Estimates annual UAM passengers will reach billions globally by 2050

Dozens of eVTOL companies are competing to capture this massive market opportunity, with Joby Aviation, Archer Aviation, and Vertical Aerospace standing out as the most prominent publicly traded companies.

---

Joby Aviation (JOBY) Deep Dive

Company Overview

Joby Aviation was founded in 2009 by JoeBen Bevirt in Santa Cruz, California. As one of the longest-established companies in the eVTOL industry, it went public on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) through a SPAC merger (Reinvent Technology Partners) in 2021.

S4 Aircraft Specifications

Joby's flagship S4 aircraft features the following specifications:

• Passengers: 1 pilot + 4 passengers
• Maximum Range: Approximately 161 km (100 miles)
• Maximum Speed: Approximately 322 km/h (200 mph)
• Noise Level: About 45 dB during cruise (at 1,500 feet altitude) - quieter than normal conversation
• Propulsion: 6 tilt propellers (vertical for takeoff/landing, horizontal for cruise)
• Power: Electric battery

Key Partnerships and Investments

• Toyota: $394 million initial investment, with subsequent rounds bringing total investment to approximately $894 million. Toyota's manufacturing expertise and quality management systems are being applied to Joby's production framework
• Delta Air Lines: Up to $200 million investment and partnership established in 2022. Joint development of air taxi services for New York/Los Angeles routes
• U.S. Department of Defense: Contracts for eVTOL military applications, participation in the Agility Prime program
• Uber Elevate: Acquired Uber's aerial taxi division, Uber Elevate, in 2020

FAA Certification Progress

Joby demonstrates the most advanced certification progress in the industry:

• Completed agreement on G-1 certification basis with FAA
• Over 1,000 test flights completed
• Part 135 Air Carrier Certificate obtained in 2024
• Commercial operations target: late 2025 to 2026

Business Model

Joby pursues a vertically integrated business model spanning aircraft manufacturing to flight service operations. Rather than selling aircraft to third parties, the company plans to operate its own air taxi service directly. This model is similar to ride-hailing platforms like Uber, but takes place in the sky.

---

Archer Aviation (ACHR) Deep Dive

Company Overview

Archer Aviation was founded in 2018 by Brett Adcock and Adam Goldstein and went public on the NYSE through a SPAC merger (Atlas Crest Financial) in 2021. The company is headquartered in San Jose, California.

Midnight Aircraft Specifications

Archer's flagship Midnight aircraft features the following specifications:

• Passengers: 1 pilot + 4 passengers
• Maximum Range: Approximately 97 km (60 miles)
• Maximum Speed: Approximately 241 km/h (150 mph)
• Noise Level: Approximately 45 dB during takeoff/landing
• Propulsion: 12 propellers (6 tilt + 6 fixed lift)
• Turnaround: Designed for approximately 10-minute charge for back-to-back flights (optimized for high-frequency short-distance operations)

Key Partnerships and Investments

• United Airlines: Up to $1 billion in Midnight pre-orders and strategic partnership. Joint development of air taxi services between airports and city centers
• Stellantis: Manufacturing partnership with the global automotive giant. Joint construction of large-scale production facility in Covington, Georgia
• U.S. Department of Defense: Military eVTOL application contracts secured, similar to Joby
• Japan Expansion: Partnerships with Japan Airlines (JAL) and Sumitomo Corporation for Japanese market entry

LA 2028 Olympics Target

Archer has set the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics as a key milestone. The strategy is to demonstrate the viability of UAM to the world by operating air taxi services during the Olympic Games. To this end, the company is pursuing vertiport infrastructure development in the LA region.

Manufacturing Strategy

Unlike Joby, Archer takes a hybrid approach combining proprietary manufacturing capabilities with external partner expertise. The core strategy is to apply Stellantis's automotive mass-production experience to eVTOL manufacturing.

---

Vertical Aerospace (EVTL) Deep Dive

Company Overview

Vertical Aerospace was founded in 2016 by Stephen Fitzpatrick in Bristol, United Kingdom. As Europe's leading eVTOL company, it went public on the NYSE through a SPAC merger (Broadstone Acquisition Corp) in 2021.

VX4 Aircraft Specifications

Vertical Aerospace's flagship VX4 targets the following specifications:

• Passengers: 1 pilot + 4 passengers
• Maximum Range: Approximately 161 km (100 miles)
• Maximum Speed: Approximately 322 km/h (200 mph)
• Noise Level: Over 100 times quieter than a helicopter
• Propulsion: Tiltrotor design
• Power: Electric battery

Key Partnerships and Investments

• Rolls-Royce: Joint development of electric propulsion systems, leveraging world-renowned expertise in aircraft engines
• Honeywell: Supply of flight control systems and avionics
• Microsoft: Cloud infrastructure and digital service support
• American Airlines: VX4 pre-orders and strategic partnership

European Market Focus Strategy

Vertical Aerospace is prioritizing certification from the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and has designated the UK and Europe as its primary markets. Short-distance urban routes with high demand in Europe (e.g., London-Brighton, Paris-Versailles) are being evaluated as initial operating corridors.

Order Book Status

Vertical Aerospace has announced approximately 1,400+ aircraft in conditional pre-orders. However, investors should note that most of these pre-orders are non-binding and contingent upon certification completion and aircraft performance verification.

---

Aircraft Specifications Comparison Table

---

FAA/EASA Certification Process and Timeline

Understanding Certification Requirements

Multiple stages of certification are required for eVTOL aircraft to conduct commercial operations:

1. Type Certificate: Proves that the aircraft design meets safety standards
2. Production Certificate: Demonstrates that production facilities and processes meet quality standards
3. Air Carrier Certificate: Part 135 (air taxi/on-demand aviation) or Part 121 (scheduled airline) certification

Part 135 vs Part 91

• Part 91: General aviation operating regulations. Applicable to privately owned aircraft operations
• Part 135: Air taxi and on-demand commercial aviation operating regulations. Required for eVTOL air taxi services
• Part 121: Scheduled airline operating regulations. Would apply if eVTOL routes eventually transition to scheduled service

Certification Timeline

FAA Special Conditions

The FAA is applying "Special Conditions" based on existing Part 23 (small aircraft) regulations to certify this entirely new category of aircraft. These address technical elements not covered by existing regulations, including electric propulsion systems, distributed electric propulsion (DEP), and battery safety.

---

Infrastructure Challenges: Vertiports, Charging, and Air Traffic Management

Vertiports

Dedicated takeoff and landing facilities called vertiports are required for eVTOL services:

• Site Selection: Utilizing building rooftops, parking structures, existing helipads in urban areas
• Design Requirements: Landing pads, charging infrastructure, passenger waiting areas, fire/safety equipment
• Regulations: Construction per FAA vertiport design guidelines (Engineering Brief No. 105)
• Cost: Estimated at several million to tens of millions of dollars per facility
• Key Operators: Skyports, Lilium (proprietary network), Ferrovial, and others

Charging Infrastructure

• High-power DC fast charging systems required (hundreds of kW class)
• Reliable power grid connections and stable electricity supply
• Battery swapping approaches also under investigation
• Archer targets high-utilization operations through 10-minute rapid charging

Air Traffic Management (ATM/UTM)

• NASA's UAM airspace management research program
• FAA Innovate28 initiative
• Integration with existing air traffic control systems required
• Growing role of AI-based traffic management systems as autonomous flight capabilities develop

---

Financial Comparison Analysis

Cash Position and Burn Rate

Note: Above figures are estimates based on recently published quarterly reports. Actual numbers may vary.

Revenue Generation Timeline

All three companies have yet to generate meaningful revenue. Even after commercial operations begin, reaching profitability is expected to take considerable time.

• Joby: Initial commercial revenue expected in 2026-2027
• Archer: Initial revenue expected in 2026-2027, focused on United Airlines routes
• Vertical: Revenue generation expected from 2027-2028 onward

TAM (Total Addressable Market) Claims

TAM figures presented in each company's investor presentations tend to be highly optimistic:

• Joby: Opportunity worth tens of billions annually in the global short-distance transportation market
• Archer: US urban air taxi market alone worth tens of billions
• Vertical: Hundreds of billions in the European and global regional aviation market

Investors should evaluate realistic penetration rates and achievable market size conservatively rather than accepting these TAM figures at face value.

---

Competitive Landscape: Other Key Players

Lilium - Lessons from Bankruptcy

German eVTOL company Lilium was once considered one of the industry's most promising players but filed for bankruptcy in late 2024 due to funding shortfalls. Lilium's case provides several important lessons:

• eVTOL development requires far more capital than initially anticipated
• Funds raised through SPAC listings alone may be insufficient to reach certification
• Proprietary technology (ducted fan approach) does not necessarily guarantee market advantage
• Risk of failing to secure government subsidies/emergency funding

Note: A European investor consortium subsequently showed interest in acquiring Lilium's assets, leaving open the possibility of partial company restructuring.

EHang (China)

• China's leading eVTOL company, first in the world to obtain type certification for an autonomous eVTOL (EH216-S)
• Certification from the Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC) obtained in 2023
• Differentiated from Western competitors through unmanned autonomous flight approach
• Already conducting pilot operations for tourism, short-distance transportation, and logistics
• Advantaged by the large Chinese domestic market, but global expansion constrained by US-China tech competition

Wisk Aero (Boeing-Backed)

• Wholly owned subsidiary of Boeing, developing autonomous air taxis
• Differentiated by its long-term vision of fully autonomous, pilotless flight
• Backed by Boeing's aviation certification experience and financial resources
• Commercial operations may come later than other companies, but operational costs could be dramatically reduced once autonomous flight is achieved

Other Notable Companies

• Beta Technologies: Developing cargo/logistics eVTOL, UPS partnership
• Volocopter: German company, multicopter approach, had planned Paris Olympics demonstration flights but experienced delays
• SkyDrive: Japanese company, targeting Osaka Expo 2025 demonstration flights

---

Key Risk Factors

1. Certification Delay Risk

FAA/EASA eVTOL certification is an unprecedented process. It may take longer than expected, and additional requirements may emerge. Historically, certification of new aircraft categories has almost always been delayed.

2. Battery Technology Limitations

Current lithium-ion battery energy density (approximately 250-300 Wh/kg) imposes constraints on eVTOL range and payload capacity. The commercialization timeline of next-generation battery technologies (solid-state batteries, lithium-sulfur, etc.) is directly linked to eVTOL performance improvements.

3. Public Acceptance

Public perception of safety and acceptance of flying taxis remains unproven. Community concerns about noise, safety, and privacy could become obstacles to service expansion.

4. Regulatory Environment

• Urban airspace flight path approvals
• Noise regulations
• Privacy issues (aerial photography along flight paths, etc.)
• Complexity of global expansion due to varying regulations across countries

5. Intensifying Competition and Funding Shortages

The eVTOL industry faces fierce competition at a stage where revenue has yet to materialize. Enormous capital is required to reach certification and commercialization, and more companies may follow Lilium's path to bankruptcy.

---

FAQ

What is the biggest difference between eVTOL and helicopters?

The most significant difference is the power source. Helicopters use fossil fuel-powered turbine engines, while eVTOLs use electric motors and batteries. This results in dramatically lower noise (approximately 1/100th of helicopter levels), lower operating costs, simpler maintenance, and zero carbon emissions. Additionally, distributed electric propulsion (DEP) improves safety - if one motor fails, the aircraft can continue flying safely on the remaining motors.

Which company is the most promising among Joby, Archer, and Vertical?

Each company has distinct strengths and weaknesses, making a definitive ranking difficult. Joby benefits from the longest track record, extensive test flight experience, and Toyota's manufacturing support. Archer's strengths lie in its strong partnership with United Airlines and Stellantis's mass production capabilities. Vertical Aerospace's advantages include partnerships with aviation industry giants like Rolls-Royce and Honeywell, along with its European market positioning strategy. From an investment perspective, certification progress, cash position, and the substantive value of partnerships should all be evaluated holistically.

What is the expected price of an eVTOL air taxi ride?

Premium pricing is expected during the initial phase. The industry targets long-term pricing of $3-$5 per mile, comparable to or slightly higher than UberX. Initial pricing is expected to start at approximately $6-$9 per mile, gradually decreasing as economies of scale and technological advances take effect.

Are eVTOLs safe?

eVTOL companies claim high safety levels through distributed electric propulsion (DEP) technology. Using multiple independent motors means the aircraft can continue flying and landing safely even if one fails. Additionally, passing rigorous FAA/EASA certification ensures that commercial operations will guarantee safety levels equivalent to existing aircraft. However, large-scale commercial operational experience is still lacking, so empirical safety data will take time to accumulate.

Is UAM service possible in Korea?

The Korean government is fostering UAM as a national strategic industry. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport is conducting the K-UAM Grand Challenge, with a roadmap established targeting commercialization from 2025. Korean companies including Hanwha Systems, Hyundai Motor Company (Supernal), and Korean Air are actively participating. Routes between Seoul-Incheon Airport and within central Seoul are being evaluated as initial operating corridors.

---

References

1. Joby Aviation SEC Filings: https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&company=joby+aviation
2. Archer Aviation Investor Relations: https://www.archer.com/investor-relations
3. Vertical Aerospace Investor Relations: https://vertical-aerospace.com/investors/
4. FAA AAM (Advanced Air Mobility) Page: https://www.faa.gov/air-taxis
5. FAA Vertiport Design Guidance: https://www.faa.gov/airports/engineering/engineering_briefs/eb-105-vertiports
6. Morgan Stanley UAM Market Forecast: https://www.morganstanley.com/ideas/autonomous-aircraft
7. McKinsey AAM Report: https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/aerospace-and-defense/our-insights/future-air-mobility
8. NASA UAM Airspace Research: https://www.nasa.gov/aeronautics/urban-air-mobility/
9. EHang Official Website: https://www.ehang.com
10. Wisk Aero Official Website: https://wisk.aero

---

Practical Takeaway

Investor Checklist

If you are considering investing in eVTOL companies, be sure to verify the following:

1. Certification Progress: Continuously monitor FAA/EASA type certificate schedules and current stages. Certification delays directly impact stock prices.

2. Cash Position and Burn Rate: Verify whether sufficient funds exist to reach certification completion. Consider potential shareholder dilution from additional capital raises.

3. Substantive Value of Partnerships: Determine how binding the contracts with major airlines and manufacturers actually are, and whether real capital is being deployed.

4. Technical Differentiation: Evaluate competitive advantages in aircraft performance (range, speed, noise), manufacturing capabilities, and charging technology.

5. Regulatory Environment Changes: Monitor FAA/EASA certification policy changes and government UAM support policies across countries.

Investment Scenarios

• Bull Case: Major companies commence commercial operations in 2026-2027, public acceptance confirmed, battery technology advances improve performance -> market expands rapidly
• Base Case: Certification delayed by 1-2 years, initial operations on limited routes, gradual market expansion -> profitability takes longer than expected
• Bear Case: Further certification delays, battery technology stagnation, insufficient public acceptance, additional company bankruptcies -> overall industry growth slowdown

Key Message

The eVTOL industry is an innovative sector with enormous market opportunities, but it remains in its early stages and is accompanied by significant uncertainty. When investing, adopt a long-term perspective while using certification milestones and financial health as core evaluation criteria. Rather than concentrating on a single stock, consider diversifying across the industry or utilizing relevant ETFs.

Quiz

Q1: What is the main topic covered in "eVTOL Company Analysis - Deep Dive Comparison of Joby, Archer, and Vertical Aerospace"?

A comprehensive analysis of the leading eVTOL (electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing) companies - Joby Aviation, Archer Aviation, and Vertical Aerospace - covering technical specifications, certification progress, financial health, and competitive landscape.

Q2: What is Joby Aviation (JOBY) Deep Dive?

Company Overview Joby Aviation was founded in 2009 by JoeBen Bevirt in Santa Cruz, California. As one of the longest-established companies in the eVTOL industry, it went public on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) through a SPAC merger (Reinvent Technology Partners) in 2021.

Q3: Explain the core concept of Archer Aviation (ACHR) Deep Dive.

Company Overview Archer Aviation was founded in 2018 by Brett Adcock and Adam Goldstein and went public on the NYSE through a SPAC merger (Atlas Crest Financial) in 2021. The company is headquartered in San Jose, California.

Q4: What are the key aspects of Vertical Aerospace (EVTL) Deep Dive?

Company Overview Vertical Aerospace was founded in 2016 by Stephen Fitzpatrick in Bristol, United Kingdom. As Europe's leading eVTOL company, it went public on the NYSE through a SPAC merger (Broadstone Acquisition Corp) in 2021.

Q5: How does FAA/EASA Certification Process and Timeline work?

Understanding Certification Requirements Multiple stages of certification are required for eVTOL aircraft to conduct commercial operations: Type Certificate: Proves that the aircraft design meets safety standards Production Certificate: Demonstrates that production facilities and...